Lab-Grown vs Natural Diamonds in New Zealand
An honest side-by-side. We sell natural diamonds only, so we are not a neutral referee and we will not pretend to be. What we can do is lay out the differences plainly — including the parts that do not favour us — and show you what a natural stone actually costs from our own stock today.
◆ Chemically identical◆ Very different price◆ Very different resale◆ Both can be certified
◆ First, the honest bit
We sell natural diamonds only. Every one of the 32,867 stones in our catalogue is natural — there is not a single lab-grown stone in it. So if you came here to buy a lab-grown diamond, we cannot help you with that, and we would rather say so than take your order for something we do not hold.
What we can do is show you what you are actually comparing, and what you pay for a natural stone today.
◆ The differences that matter
| Natural | Lab-grown | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | Carbon crystallised in the earth over 1–3 billion years | The same carbon crystal, grown in a lab over weeks |
| Chemically | Pure carbon — identical to lab-grown | Pure carbon — identical to natural |
| Can you tell them apart? | Not by eye. A laboratory needs specialist equipment | Not by eye. A laboratory needs specialist equipment |
| Certificate | GIA · IGI · HRD | IGI · GIA — the report states “Laboratory Grown” |
| Price | Higher — scarcity is real | Typically 60–80% less |
| Resale | An established second-hand market | Falling as production costs keep dropping |
| Scarcity | Finite supply | Can be produced indefinitely |
◆ When a lab-grown diamond makes more sense
We will say it plainly: if the priority is the largest, cleanest stone for the money, a lab-grown diamond wins, and not by a small margin. Nobody looking at it across a table will know the difference. If you would rather have two carats than one for the same budget, that is a perfectly sensible choice.
◆ When a natural diamond makes more sense
If you want a stone that is finite — that no factory can reproduce more of — natural is the only option. That is also why it has a resale market and lab-grown, so far, does not. Plenty of buyers simply like knowing their stone is older than the human race.
◆ What a natural diamond costs today
Live prices from our own catalogue of 32,867 natural stones, in New Zealand dollars with GST included. “Typical price” is the middle of each band.
| Carat weight | From | Typical price | Up to | Stones we hold |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0.30 – 0.49 ct | $225 | $944 | $3,545 | 9,289 |
| 0.50 – 0.74 ct | $422 | $1,421 | $11,193 | 10,107 |
| 0.75 – 0.99 ct | $972 | $2,709 | $12,962 | 3,253 |
| 1.00 – 1.24 ct | $1,387 | $4,811 | $52,542 | 5,205 |
| 1.25 – 1.49 ct | $2,425 | $8,412 | $76,796 | 460 |
| 1.50 – 1.99 ct | $2,964 | $10,775 | $54,797 | 2,438 |
| 2.00 – 2.49 ct | $6,842 | $21,696 | $124,730 | 1,031 |
| 2.50 – 2.99 ct | $12,561 | $46,182 | $116,051 | 109 |
| 3.00 ct and above | $17,370 | $94,495 | $7,042,017 | 495 |
For comparison, here is the same weight with and without an independent laboratory report:
| 1.00 – 1.09 ct | Stones we hold | Typical price |
|---|---|---|
| Certified (GIA · IGI · HRD) | 3,672 | $5,002 |
| Graded in-house (non-certified) | 672 | $2,758 |
See every natural diamond we hold →
◆ Frequently asked questions
Are lab-grown diamonds real diamonds?
Yes. They are pure carbon with the same crystal structure, the same hardness of 10 on the Mohs scale and the same optical properties as a mined diamond. The only difference is origin.
Can a jeweller tell the difference?
Not by eye. Specialist equipment detects the growth patterns and trace elements that give away lab creation — which is exactly why the certificate states it.
How much cheaper is a lab-grown diamond?
Typically well below the price of an equivalent natural stone, and the gap widens as production scales. That is why many buyers choose lab-grown when size matters more than long-term resale value.
Do lab-grown diamonds hold their value?
Historically they have not. Production costs keep falling, so today's lab-grown price is usually above tomorrow's. Natural diamonds have a long-established second-hand market.
Do lab-grown diamonds come with certificates?
Yes — IGI and GIA both issue laboratory-grown reports that describe colour, clarity, cut and measurements using the same language as a natural report, and state clearly that the stone is laboratory-grown.
Do you sell lab-grown diamonds?
No. Everything in our catalogue today is a natural stone — 32,867 of them. We would rather tell you that plainly than sell you a stone we do not hold. If you want to see what we do hold, the full listing is one click away, and the price tables on this page show exactly what a natural stone costs.
Is a natural diamond worth the extra money?
For most buyers of an engagement stone, yes — the report is independent, the stone is finite, and it holds a resale market. At 1.00 – 1.09 ct our certified natural stones sit around a median of NZ$5,002, against NZ$2,758 for the same weight graded in-house. If you would rather have two carats than one for the same money, a lab-grown stone is a perfectly sensible choice.
What should I buy if my budget is fixed?
Decide what the stone is for. A ring that is set once and worn every day is usually worth buying natural. A travel piece, an anniversary band or a set of studs where size matters more is where lab-grown makes sense.
◆ Where to go next
- How lab-grown diamonds are actually made
- Every natural diamond in stock
- What a laboratory report actually tells you
- Work out what a diamond should cost you
Every count and price on this page comes from our live catalogue — 32,867 natural stones, harvested 16 November 2026. New Zealand prices include GST.